By Marisa Dawson, Photos Courtesy of Bennington Community Theatre

Group of people in Victorian-era costumes posing on a wooden staircase inside a historic home

Bennington Community Theatre is finding new ways to bring people together, and its latest fundraising event proved that sometimes a little mystery can go a long way.

The theater recently hosted its first mystery dinner, welcoming guests to the historic Gordon-Oft House in downtown Bennington for an immersive evening of clues, characters and crime-solving. The inaugural event raised more than $4,000 to support the organization’s continued growth and upcoming opportunities.

Unlike a traditional dinner theater production, guests weren’t simply seated to watch a performance unfold. Instead, they became part of the story, moving freely through six rooms of the historic home to interrogate six character suspects, collect clues and work to solve the mystery. The evening also included two drink tickets, individual charcuterie cups and a campfire marshmallow roast to wrap up the experience.

The concept grew out of a combination of past experiences and inspiration from other events. BCT Founder Blake Thompson said the idea brought together elements he and co-founder Donna Dahlsten (both pictured below) had encountered over the years.

Two production team members posing in period costumes behind a sign reading “Production Team” in a candlelit Victorian-style setting.

“The idea came from a mix of things that Donna and I have experienced. She used to do progressive dinners in the Victorian style and organize a Cemetery Walk in Hastings that had a similar feel. I had heard of an area event that did something similar so when we worked on this, it mended all of these ideas together,” Thompson said.

Dahlsten wrote and directed the mystery script, while Thompson served as producer and stage manager, helping coordinate the evening and keep everything running smoothly. All nine members of the theater’s board contributed to the event, taking on roles as suspects or working behind the scenes to coordinate refreshments, logistics, clues and the flow of the evening. Two additional local actors, both of whom had participated in previous theater productions, also joined the cast.

The event provided an opportunity to reach beyond the theater’s usual audience, something organizers were particularly excited to see.

Although the event didn’t completely sell out, Dahlsten said organizers were pleased with attendance and especially encouraged by the number of new faces who came out to participate.

“Several guests mentioned it was the best mystery event they had attended in quite some time and told us they really hope we do it again,” Dahlsten said. “Ultimately, we feel like we’re offering a fresh, engaging theatrical experience for people who want to be part of the action rather than just ‘sit and watch’.”

The success of the evening was made possible through community support, including the generosity of Linda and Gordon Mueller, as well as event sponsor the Wickham Family.

Thompson said the more than $4,000 raised will primarily support the operations of the theater’s new space. The organization hopes to use those funds to help cover the startup costs associated with productions, workshops and other experiences, allowing individual events to break even without having to rely on additional fundraising or sponsors.

“The Theatre is committed to producing quality shows, productions, workshops and experiences and will fund those start-up costs for each event in order for it to break even, meaning it doesn’t have to fundraise or find sponsors,” Thompson said. “In order to do that, we must raise the funds as an entire board and be strong fiscal agents of our dollars.”

The theater is also considering whether the mystery dinner could become an annual tradition. Thompson said the board has discussed bringing it back but will continue evaluating the organization’s available volunteers and finances before making a decision.

A permanent home for community theater

The fundraiser comes at an exciting time for Bennington Community Theatre, which recently announced it has secured a new rehearsal and venue space at Oft’s Ballroom, located above Nate’s Stumble Inn.

The location is somewhat familiar to the organization. Thompson said the theater used the ballroom for its very first production, and the experience helped demonstrate its potential as a long-term home.

The space offers several advantages, including an affordable arrangement, exclusive access for the theater, a convenient location and existing performance features such as a stage. Just as importantly, it provides the opportunity to bring rehearsals and performances together under one roof while accommodating a sizable audience.

The theater plans to begin moving its belongings into the space in January, including its storage and rehearsal materials. The ballroom also offers a private entrance dedicated to BCT, along with access to storage rooms and other areas for the organization.

While the theater hopes to host as many productions and events at the new location as possible, some performances will continue to take place elsewhere. The organization’s mainstage production during Bennington Daze will remain at Bennington High School, while other productions are expected to transition to the ballroom.

Work on preparing the new space will begin in the new year, with the theater targeting its first production there for the 2027-2028 season. That inaugural show is planned to be the Founder’s Day 2027 production.

For an organization that has spent years coordinating rehearsals and performances around available community spaces, having a permanent home represents an important change. Thompson said the dedicated space will allow the theater to become more self-sufficient and expand what it can offer.

“We have been so appreciative of our community partners for allowing us to use their space, but in the end, it’s still their space,” Thompson said. “This will allow directors to build a set, work on things, etc. at their own leisure as well as allow us to keep more props, costumes, etc.”

The additional flexibility will give directors and production teams more freedom to develop shows, prepare sets and organize materials without having to work around another organization’s schedule or available facilities.

“For so long, we’ve been making theater wherever we could find room, and now we finally have a permanent home right in the heart of our community,” Dahlsten said.

The organization hopes the ballroom will become more than just a place to rehearse and perform. Dahlsten said the goal is to create a gathering place where local artists can grow and community members feel welcome. In the coming year, audiences can look forward to a lineup of shows, continued workshops and additional opportunities to get involved both on and off the stage.

Between a successful new fundraising event and a permanent home on the horizon, Bennington Community Theatre is looking ahead to a new chapter, one with plenty of room for creativity, collaboration and a little theatrical mystery.


Discover more from Bennington Buzz

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Trending